When you shop for vanilla beans, you'll see products labeled Grade A and Grade B. The naming is a bit counterintuitive — Grade B sounds inferior, but for one major use case it's actually the better choice.
Here's exactly what each grade means and when to use which.
What Makes a Bean "Grade A"?
Grade A beans — sometimes called "gourmet" or "prime" — are:
- Plump and moist: At least 25–30% moisture content
- Long: Usually 6–8 inches
- Flexible: They bend without snapping
- Shiny: A slightly oily surface is a sign of quality
- Seed-rich: Packed with black vanilla caviar inside
These beans are beautiful to work with. When you split and scrape a Grade A bean over a pot of warm cream, the seeds disperse easily, the aroma is intense, and the visual result is exactly what you want.
Shop Grade A Madagascar Vanilla Beans
Best uses for Grade A:
- Ice cream base (steeping in warm milk/cream)
- Crème brûlée, panna cotta, custard
- Vanilla sugar
- Any recipe where you're scraping the seeds directly into the dish
- Situations where the look of the vanilla specks matters
What Makes a Bean "Grade B"?
Grade B beans — also called "extract grade" — are:
- Drier: 15–25% moisture content
- Slightly shorter and thinner on average
- Less visually impressive: May have slight blemishes or splits
- Just as flavorful — often more concentrated vanilla compound per ounce due to lower moisture
The key point: Grade B beans have less water, which means more vanilla flavor compounds per gram of bean. This makes them ideal for extract-making, where you want maximum extraction into the alcohol.
Shop Grade B Madagascar Vanilla Beans
Best uses for Grade B:
- Homemade vanilla extract (this is their designed purpose)
- Vanilla powder
- Any infusion where the bean will be strained out
The Price Difference
Grade A beans almost always cost more than Grade B — sometimes significantly more. For extract-making, you're paying a premium for moisture and appearance that doesn't translate into a better extract.
If you're buying beans specifically to make extract, Grade B is the smarter purchase. Spend those savings on more beans, or on better vodka.
Can You Use Grade A for Extract?
Yes. Grade A beans make perfectly good extract. You're just paying for visual qualities that don't contribute to extract flavor. If you happen to have Grade A beans and want to make extract, go for it — you'll get a great result.
Similarly, can you use Grade B beans for scraping? Technically yes, but they're harder to work with (drier, less pliant) and yield fewer visible seeds. For dishes where the specks matter, Grade A is worth the price.
Quick Decision Guide
Use Grade A when: You're scraping beans directly into a recipe, making vanilla sugar, infusing dairy, or gifting whole beans.
Use Grade B when: You're making homemade vanilla extract or vanilla powder.
Either works for: Any recipe where the bean is strained out and you're just after the flavor.
This post contains affiliate links. We only recommend products we've actually used.